Blog

Should I Repair My Roof or Replace My Roof?

March 13, 2023

Are you experiencing shingles scattered around your yard or noticing leaks on your ceiling? If so, you're not alone. As someone who has been in the roofing and construction industry for over 40 years, I understand how frustrating these issues can be. The good news is that your roof can be repaired in most cases. However, there comes a time when replacing your roof is the only option.

At TQR Roofing, we've been providing residents in the state of Maryland with high-quality roof repair and replacement services since 1992. Our team is committed to providing honest and reliable workmanship, ensuring you'll never have to worry about your roof again.

The big question is, how do you know which option is suitable for your roof? Fortunately, we have the answer. Whether you need roof repairs or a full roof replacement, we're here to help you make the best decision for you and your home. So, let's explore your options together and find the right solution to keep your roof in tip-top shape.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Repairing or Replacing Your Roof

Before deciding whether to repair or replace your roof, there are several factors you should take into account. These may include the age of your roof, your plans for staying in your home, and other considerations that can help you determine whether it's time to replace your roof or if repairs will suffice.

What is the age of my roof?

When it comes to asphalt shingles, the age of your roof is a crucial factor to consider when deciding between repair or replacement. If you're uncertain about the age of your roof, a reputable roofing contractor can provide you with an estimate of its remaining lifespan.

For lower-end three-tab shingles, you can expect a lifespan of 15 to 20 years. However, higher-quality architectural shingles can last up to 40 years and withstand wind speeds up to 130 MPH. With these varying lifespans, it's essential to know the type of shingles on your roof to help determine if repair or replacement is necessary.

Signs That Your Roof is Aging:

  • Curling or Buckling Shingles
  • Bald Spots on Shingles
  • Missing Shingles
  • Sagging Roof
  • Presence of Moss on Your Roof
  • Blistering Shingles
  • Granules in the Gutter

It's crucial to consult with multiple roofing companies before making a decision. Unfortunately, there are instances where homeowners have been told that their roofs require replacement when it's not necessary. Some companies may push for a roof replacement even if it's not warranted, regardless of your roof's condition or age.

What is my long-term plan for staying in my home?

If you're not planning to live in your current home permanently, it may not be practical to invest in a new roof. However, when it's time to sell your home, the condition and age of your roof can make it challenging to find a buyer.

On the other hand, if you intend to stay in your home, it's advisable to have a roofing contractor inspect your roof if it has undergone several repairs or is between 15 and 20 years old. If your roof is in good condition, it's recommended to schedule routine maintenance at least once or twice a year to extend its lifespan.

Suppose you plan to sell your home in the future, and your roof is damaged or in poor condition, it could be difficult to find a buyer. In such cases, a new roof installation may be the best option to enhance your home's curb appeal and increase its resale value. It's important to note that upon selling, you can recoup up to 68% of the cost of replacing your roof.

What is the estimated budget for replacing my roof?

For some homeowners, a roof replacement may not be feasible due to financial constraints. In such cases, a reliable roofing company should be able to offer temporary repair solutions until you are financially ready for a full roof replacement.

Should I Repair My Roof?

Opting for roof repairs is often the most economical solution to address any roofing issues. By repairing your roof, you can prolong the lifespan of your current roof, giving you sufficient time to save up for a future roof replacement.

There are several signs that indicate the need for roof repair. Here are some of them:

  • Leaks around the Pipe Boot
  • Leaks Around the Chimney
  • Missing shingles
  • Air Gun Nailing Mistakes
  • Nail pops
  • Fascia Replacement
  • Punctures and Holes
  • Cracking and Blistering
  • Poor Installation
  • Tree Damage
  • Weather Damage
  • Granule Loss
  • Splitting
  • Shrinkage
  • Poor Maintenance
  • Ventilation Problems

Benefits of roof repairs

Roof repairing versus roof replacement is a cost-effective solution.

Repairing a roof is generally less expensive than replacing it. Certain components of a roof have a shorter lifespan compared to the entire roof system.

By repairing your roof, you can extend its lifespan.

Inquire with your roofing contractor about possible repair options before opting for a replacement. Opting for repairs instead of replacement can prolong your roof's longevity. It's a straightforward approach to maintaining your roof's condition.

Disadvantages of roof repairs

Finding the right color match for shingles can present a challenge.

As shingles age, they tend to fade due to prolonged sun exposure. This makes it challenging to find a perfect match for replacing a shingle. Matching the colors of new shingles to the existing ones is almost impossible. Consequently, it can lead to an unattractive curb appeal that can be noticeable not only to you but also to your neighbors.

Poor craftsmanship may result in complications and leakages in the roof.

Roof repair is a highly specialized field that demands skilled professionals to execute the job effectively. Repairing and installing roofs require different expertise. An inexperienced individual may cause more harm than good, resulting in further damage to the roof.

Should I Replace My Roof?

Determining the appropriate time to replace your roof hinges on various considerations, such as its age, wear and tear, installation quality, and the likelihood of potential damage to your property.

If a full replacement is necessary, below are the advantages and disadvantages of opting for a replacement.

Benefits of a roof replacement

Installing a new roof enhances the aesthetic appeal of your home's exterior.

A new roof accounts for 40% of your property's exterior appeal. Curb appeal is a crucial factor that can either make or break the first impression of your home. By replacing your old roof with a new one, you can add a positive touch to your property's curb appeal.

An outdated roof can make your home look weary, but a fresh replacement can make it appear brand new. The benefits of replacing your roof go beyond aesthetics, as it can also offer long-term peace of mind. Additionally, a new roof can make your home the envy of the neighborhood.

Replacing your roof provides a sense of reassurance and security.

After replacing your roof, you can leave town without worrying about the weather conditions back home. You won't have to face any leaks or damages upon your return. This reassurance can offer you peace of mind.

Disadvantages of a roof replacement

Replacing a roof can be a noisy process.

Many homeowners prefer to be present while their roof is being replaced, unaware of the potential noise level during the shingle installation. As a professional recommendation, it's wise to plan to be away from the property during this process to avoid the noise disruption caused by the installation of new shingles.

During a roof replacement, it might be advisable to relocate your pets.

While you may anticipate the noise from the roof replacement and decide to stay outside, it's important to consider your pets' wellbeing as well. Many homeowners have left their dogs and cats at home during the roof installation, but some pets may find the experience overwhelming. Dogs can usually adapt quickly to the noise, but cats may become anxious and disappear for days. As a precaution, it might be best to send your pets to a daycare center or have a friend care for them while the work is being done.

Some roofing companies may not cleanup properly after completing a roof replacement.

After completing a residential roof replacement, some roofing companies may neglect to perform the necessary inspection and cleanup, leaving behind a mess. This final 10% of the work is crucial for ensuring that your property remains free from debris and nails that could harm your family and guests, damage your tires, or cause havoc in your attic. Inadequate cleanup can also make your attic look like a battlefield. To prevent this, make sure the roofer you hire lays down plastic or a tarp to protect your stored items from debris.

What To Do Next?

When it comes to getting your roof repaired or replaced, it's important to keep a few things in mind before signing any contracts. One of the most crucial things to do is research. This means educating yourself on the types of repairs or replacements that may be necessary, as well as understanding the terminology and jargon used in the industry.

By doing your research, you can also ensure that you're not being taken advantage of by unscrupulous roofing companies. Take the time to check out reviews for each company you're considering and choose one that has a solid reputation in the industry. It's also important to choose a company that is able to answer any questions you have and provides you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Before calling in a roofing company to inspect your roof, it's also a good idea to educate yourself on the condition of your roof. This means knowing the age of your roof, the types of materials used, and any potential issues or damage that may be present. This information will help you to better understand what a roofer or salesperson will be explaining to you, and will enable you to ask the right questions to ensure that you get the best possible service.

Get a second opinion

It is essential to be cautious when it comes to roof replacement, as it is a significant investment. If a salesman or a roofing company suggests a roof replacement, it is always recommended to call in another company to come and inspect your roof as well. It's not uncommon to come across homeowners who have been given different quotes from various roofing companies, and all they needed was a simple repair instead of a full replacement.

In such cases, it is advisable to go with a company that has a proven track record of being honest, educating customers, and doing things the right way. It's crucial to do your research and choose a roofing company that will give you a detailed assessment of your roof, including its condition and any underlying issues, and advise you on the best course of action that will fit your needs and budget. Remember, the roofing industry has one of the highest complaint rates filed with the Better Business Bureau, so make sure you choose a reputable and reliable roofing company.

Choose a local company you trust

To ensure that your roof is properly taken care of, it's crucial to find a local roofing contractor that you can trust. It's important to do thorough research and find a reputable company that is licensed, bonded, and insured.

Ask questions and make sure you feel comfortable with the company that will be working on your roof. Your roof is essential for protecting you, your family, and your belongings. It's the most critical aspect of your home's structure, so it's crucial to choose a trustworthy and reliable roofing company to ensure that your roof is in good hands.

Ready for a roof repair or a roof replacement?

To determine the condition of your roof, it's necessary to have it inspected by a reliable roofing contractor. It's difficult to know exactly what repairs or maintenance is needed until a thorough inspection has been completed. To ensure an honest evaluation, it's important to choose a roofing contractor that you can trust.

If you're in need of a roof inspection, consider contacting TQR Roofing for a free, no-obligation consultation. Our team of experts will provide a thorough inspection and offer recommendations based on your unique situation. With our commitment to honesty and transparency, you can trust that we will provide you with accurate information and quality service.

Top Quality Remodeling & Restoration

When an unexpected disaster hits your home or business, you need an honest and dependable company available to help you 24/7.

Get in touch